Skip to main content
  • Genre:

    Pop/R&B

  • Label:

    Nuyorican / BMG

  • Reviewed:

    February 22, 2024

With throwback beats and baroque pop embellishments, J. Lo’s first solo album in 10 years chronicles a real-life fairy tale that threatens to overpower the music.

Did you hear about the two Hollywood megastars who got engaged, broke up in the shadow of a notorious workplace accident, and then, 20 years and several partners later, finally got hitched? If you somehow missed it, Jennifer Lopez is going to tell you in detail. This Is Me…Now, her first solo album in 10 years, is a coda to 2002’s This Is Me…Then, her third most commercially successful album. Lopez co-wrote and released that record amid the first iteration of her high-profile relationship with handsome Bostonian Ben Affleck. This Is Me…Now is the culmination of Bennifer, the sequel, irresistible to tabloids and hopeless romantics, maybe in that order. “When I was a girl they’d ask me what I’d be/A woman in love is what I grew up wantin’ to be,” Lopez sings, rather depressingly, on the title track.

The album, and its accompanying $20 million movie, unfolds like one of J.Lo’s romcoms: Two former lovers, adrift, spend years searching for the right person, before reuniting with the wisdom of age and experience. The movie loosely follows the Taíno legend of Alida, the daughter of a Taíno chief who falls in forbidden love with Taroo, a Carib boy, on the eve of her arranged marriage; the god Yukiyú turns them into a red flower and a hummingbird, respectively. (The light pop joint “Hummingbird” bisects the album, though it doesn’t quite engage the mythology enough to be readily meaningful.) J.Lo is lovestruck as fuck, this album posits, though it is self-aware about its melodrama. “Mad in Love,” a mid-tempo R&B track, opens with a flute and string section out of a 1950s romance, nodding to This Is Me…Now’s Hollywood love story. Otherworldly harps, celestas, and violins weave through beats and production of a mid-2000s vintage, supplying a baroque quality that embellishes J.Lo’s own lovelorn legend.

Across eight previous studio albums, a cache of hits like 2001’s “I’m Real” and 2011’s “On the Floor,” a Super Bowl performance and a presidential inauguration, J.Lo’s voice is notoriously serviceable, airy and light with a very specific range. A major appeal of her pop stardom is that the one-time Fly Girl is consistently dazzling on the dancefloor and, at 54, she appears athletic, taut, cool as ever. She’s advanced her music career through will and sheer charisma, of which she has gobs—we’re talking about a woman who had many of us out here wearing newsboy caps and cargo knickers in the early ’00s. She is an all-around entertainer, a fashion icon, and an often-great actor to boot. (Most will cite Hustlers, Selena, and Out of Sight; I’ll agree with J.Lo that she deserved an Oscar nod for El Cantante.) And so the thinness of the voice has often been beside the point, if not a boon to her early career—a stand-in for her Bronx regularness on tracks like “Jenny From the Block.”

What Lopez has had in abundance, though, is terrific hooks: “All I Have,” “Still,” and the cultural touchstone (complete with Ben cameo) “Jenny,” from This Is Me… Then. She serves some of that here, too: “To Be Yours” includes one of Now’s catchier hooks, with J.Lo asserting her love in a chatty alto. “not.going.anywhere.” falls precisely within her pop oeuvre, light and primed for choreo, with a chill rap interlude and a purposeful throwback beat. (And, in case you forgot who this album is about, an intro by Ben Affleck.) Her voice is stronger than ever, honed on a succession of recent pop-reggaeton singles like “Cambia al Paso” and “Pa Ti,” though those styles are sorely missed on Now (even though everyone knows Ben speaks Spanish!). So “This Time Around” stands out for its synth marimbas and trunk-slapping woofers, and for the moment when the Nuyorican we know and love jumps out: “This time around, we gon’ make it real/We don’t give a fuck ’bout how they feel,” she sings vehemently.

This Is Me…Now is a multimedia memoir, meant to explore Lopez’s past relationship difficulties (“Rebound,” “Broken Like Me”) but more prominently displaying her fairy-tale perfect ending. If your friend were doing this, you might sit them down for a serious chat; evidently some of Lopez’s friends did. No detail is spared, if embellished. Do you need to know that the couple changed into their wedding outfits in the Vegas chapel bathroom? “Midnight Trip to Vegas” has you covered with a Chris Isaak sample and a lute, a sound that lands somewhere between Final Fantasy VII and an unexpectedly popping Renaissance Faire. “Dear Ben, Pt. II,” co-written by Raye, improves on the original with a grounded harp and even a little vibrato. I guess if your business is already on blast, there’s no harm in globally projecting your album-length love letter to your husband, but after a certain point the specificity is entirely too much. The lyric “said you love my body but it’s still my face” is cute; by the time she sings “slippin’ inside of me” on “Greatest Love Story Never Told,” the vivid imagery it conjures is unfortunately permanent.

That’s This Is Me…Now’s biggest issue: the narrative threatens to, and does, overtake the music. While the songs might be fun and even better with choreography, the Disney Princess angle becomes tiresome, and then cloying, especially from a woman who has notoriously worked her ass off to achieve her level of renown. “Hearts and Flowers” tries to mitigate that—it’s a boom-bap song about her dedication to the grind that somewhat awkwardly calls back to “Jenny From the Block”—but as her childhood dream apparently forecast, being in love with Ben Affleck is the primary focus. As a synergistic mythmaking effort, the album is certainly doing its job; as music to soundtrack your actual life, well, it’s about time lute pop got its shine.

All products featured on Pitchfork are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Jennifer Lopez: This Is Me...Now