Fans Think Hilary Duff and Victoria Pedretti Are Celebrity Lookalikes

Get ready to do a double-take, because there’s a new celeb lookalike pair in town, and it’s none other than Hilary Duff and Victoria Pedretti.

Yep, some fans couldn’t help but notice the resemblance while watching Season 2 of You on Netflix, noticing that the two actors could easily play on-screen sisters. (Some viewers even brought Kat Dennings into the mix, saying that the actor who plays Love Quinn could easily be the love-child of grown-up Lizzie McGuire and the Dollface star. The mind-bending, it’s too much!)

Of course, the Victoria/Hilary doppelgänger theory is made even more complex when you remember that Hilary appeared on Gossip Girl with You’s Penn Badgley. The 32-year-old portrayed Olivia Burke, who entered into a romance with Dan Humphrey, played by Penn. There’s definitely some crossover / alternate universe here where Joe and Dan just might be the same person, right?

We’ll have to wait and see if either Victoria or Hilary weigh in on the comparison themselves, but it’s understandable if they don’t have time — both actors are pretty busy these days! Victoria is expected to appear on our screens again in The Haunting of Bly Manor, the follow-up chapter to Netflix’s critically acclaimed Haunting of Hill House. Meanwhile, Hilary is currently enjoying her honeymoon in South Africa along with husband Matthew Koma, while gearing up to reprise her fan-favorite role on the Disney+ Lizzie McGuire reboot. But hey, with a Season 3 of You possibly in the works, maybe there’s room for Hilary to play Love’s long-lost triplet. Stranger things have (most definitely) happened on that show!

Want more from Teen Vogue? Check this out:

• Victoria Pedretti Has Thoughts on Love Quinn’s You Twist
• Hilary Duff Unveiled Gorgeous Photos of Her Wedding Gown